Application Toolkit

Testing in College Admissions Guide

By College Solutions Team / August 20, 2026

★ Quick Take / Executive Summary

The college admissions testing landscape features a spectrum of policies ranging from test-required to test-blind. Students should take standardized tests to keep their options open, but must strategically evaluate their scores against a college's historical averages before deciding to submit them.

As the global COVID-19 pandemic unfolded, the college admissions landscape underwent massive transformations, especially regarding SAT and ACT requirements. What began as a temporary necessity has permanently changed the testing landscape.

With the rapid evolution of test-optional, test-flexible, and test-blind models across higher education, students are often torn over whether they should invest considerable time and money into test prep. Here is everything you need to know about navigating testing policies today.

The Evolution of College Admissions Testing

When test centers closed worldwide due to the pandemic, colleges and universities across the U.S. pivoted away from their traditional SAT or ACT requirements. By adopting test-optional policies, institutions ensured that applicants were not disadvantaged by circumstances beyond their control.

While some institutions viewed test-optional policies as a temporary, emergency measure, many others saw the pandemic as a catalyst for permanent change in their admissions philosophy. Today, the diversity in policy adoption reflects varying institutional values across the higher education sector.

As the educational community navigates these changes, the focus remains on fostering a fair and equitable admissions process. However, the lack of uniformity means that applicants must pay closer attention to individual college testing requirements than ever before.

Understanding the Spectrum of Testing Policies

Not all testing policies are created equal. It is critical to understand the nuances of how different institutions evaluate standardized tests. The most predominant approach is the Test-Optional policy, where students choose whether to submit scores. If a student opts out, they are not penalized during the application or scholarship review.

Conversely, some prestigious universities—including MIT, Georgetown, and Dartmouth—have reverted to Test-Required models. These institutions cite standardized tests as a highly predictive measure of academic success and a valuable tool for evaluating readiness across diverse socioeconomic backgrounds.

On the other end of the spectrum are Test-Blind and Test-Flexible models. The University of California system is proudly Test-Blind, meaning they will not consider SAT or ACT scores even if submitted. Meanwhile, Test-Flexible schools, like Yale, allow applicants to submit alternative exam scores (such as AP or IB results) in place of traditional SAT/ACT scores.

To Test or Not to Test?

With so much uncertainty about requirements, many juniors wonder if they should even bother preparing for the SAT or ACT. The best approach is to prepare for and take the exams, keeping all of your options open. Even test-optional schools value students who submit scores that fall above their historical averages.

If your test scores accurately reflect your academic capabilities and strengthen your profile, submit them. If they do not, and the school is test-optional, you can confidently withhold them and allow your high school transcript to speak for itself.

Beyond the SAT and ACT: Changing Metrics

Even with the uncertainty surrounding the SAT and ACT, other testing metrics have undergone clear changes. For instance, the College Board permanently eliminated the optional SAT Writing Assessment, as colleges found it to be a poor measure of a student’s actual writing skills.

Furthermore, the College Board also eliminated the SAT Subject Tests for U.S. students. In their absence, colleges are placing greater emphasis on AP and IB exams.

Taking advanced coursework and sitting for AP or IB exams is now one of the strongest ways to demonstrate competency in specific subject areas. While these exams do not replace the SAT or ACT at test-required schools, they are increasingly vital in holistic admissions reviews.

Final Thoughts

The approach to SAT and ACT testing in college admissions will continue to evolve. Because the landscape is no longer 'one size fits all,' a strategic, individualized approach is essential.

By understanding the different testing models and working closely with an advisor, you can build a testing strategy that maximizes your strengths and positions you for success in the admissions process.

Ready? We are.

Whether you’ve got questions about our packages and add-ons, what sets College Solutions apart, or you’re ready to get to work with our admissions experts to help your student navigate their journey to the perfect college fit, schedule a free consultation so we can get to know your family.