Admissions Strategy

10 Suggestions to Engage Your Reluctant Student

By Sarah Dohl / June 19, 2021
Engaging a reluctant student in the college search process
VIEW FULL

★ Quick Take / Executive Summary

When high schoolers seem disengaged from the college search, it usually stems from fear, overwhelm, or uncertainty rather than a lack of motivation. Parents can re-engage them by pinpointing underlying anxieties, keeping conversations casual, visiting local campuses, using tangible incentives, and letting external counselors share the guidance burden.

Practical strategies for breaking through college planning resistance and overwhelm.

Feel like you’re dragging your high schooler through the college stuff? When a student is not engaged, to parents it looks a lot like lack of motivation. More likely, though, your student is feeling overwhelmed about the unknowns, confused about major and career interests, or fearful—fear of moving away, fear of failure, or fear of letting family down. Here are practical ideas to bring your child along.

STEP 01

1. Pinpoint the Cause of Reluctance

01

College may loom as a scary place, something that has been held over their heads for years as an ultimatum rather than an exciting reward. Ask open questions, allow them to express their feelings, and listen.

Once you understand their hesitation, you can break tasks down into tiny, manageable parts. If their hesitation comes from something deeper, like severe anxiety or depression, arrange for professional support first.

STEP 02

2. Bring College into Daily Conversation

02

While watching a sporting match or game, ask if they've heard of the competing schools and pull up campus photos together.

Talk about aspects of college you know will draw them in—certain courses they long to take, specialized clubs, or independent living.

STEP 03

3. Get Them Excited About Campus Life

03

Focus on aspects of the undergraduate experience that genuinely draw them in, such as unique student organizations or independence.

Showcase how college is a platform for personal freedom and self-discovery rather than just an extension of high school pressure.

STEP 04

4. Career Clarity & Major Exploration

04

For students stalled by career path confusion, helping them figure out what they like and what they’re suited for can lead to some clarity.

Instead of asking what they want to major in, ask what their favorite classes have been and why, or how they would construct an entire day if given absolute freedom. Remind them that entering college 'Undeclared' is a completely valid choice.

STEP 05

5. Strategic Bribes & Positive Reinforcement

05

If you know what might motivate your kid, use that—money or video games. Come up with a reward system for academic work.

Tie the process to exploration and experience, not the final achievement. Ask them to put together a resume for a day off, or write a first essay draft for weekend car privileges.

STEP 06

6. Casual Campus Visits Close to Home

06

Make some casual college visits starting with those closest to home, like your local state university.

Sign up for the official tour, but spend plenty of time wandering the student union, library, and bookstore to demystify the environment.

STEP 07

7. Let Others Share the Burden

07

Let others share the burden, like independent counselors, high school guidance departments, and college admissions reps.

Put the burden on the colleges to make their pitch. Your teen will often believe outside experts over years of parental advice.

STEP 08

8. Make the Process More Fun

08

Suggest getting take-out breakfast and talking about college on the way to pick up.

If there is a college near a baseball game or amusement park, visit the campus first and end the day with a fun reward.

STEP 09

9. Avoid Pressure and Comparison

09

Don’t pressure and don’t compare your child to others and what other kids are doing.

Most high school students are willing to discuss options if they know their wishes and goals are taken seriously. Don't panic if they express uncertainty; other valuable paths exist.

STEP 10

10. Give Them Autonomy Over the Process

10

Maybe you let them work out the details of their college visit trips and itinerary.

Recognize when they accomplish something independently—like reaching out to an admissions officer—and praise them for taking initiative.

Moving Forward with Confidence

Reluctance is rarely about a lack of ambition; it is almost always about navigating fear, uncertainty, and the massive scale of the unknown.

By giving your student room to explore at their own pace, celebrating small efforts, and offering steady support, you can help them find genuine excitement and purpose on their path to college.

Ready? We are.

Whether you’ve got questions about our packages and add-ons, what sets College Solutions apart, or you’re ready to get to work with our admissions experts to help your student navigate their journey to the perfect college fit, schedule a free consultation so we can get to know your family.