Standardized testing in admissions now spans test-optional, test-expected (Purdue), and no-harm (Denison) policies. As discussed by Patrick Zylka, Compass Education Group, and university admissions directors, test scores remain a single factor within holistic evaluations balancing transcript rigor, essays, and extracurricular involvement.
Making Sense of New Testing Vocabulary
The vocabulary around testing has expanded beyond required or optional to include 'no harm', 'test expected', and classic 'test optional'. While some highly selective and large state institutions have reinstated testing, the overall movement leans toward giving students control. Denison's 'no harm' approach means sending a lower score will not hurt, nor will withholding one. Kansas State emphasized that test-optional does not mean test-irrelevant for competitive programs or merit aid. Purdue highlighted their 'test expected' policy, where scores provide a valued data point in holistic review.
Scores Aren’t Everything
Holistic review evaluates test scores as just one component alongside grades, coursework rigor, extracurricular activities, essays, and recommendation letters. Colleges use these combined factors to evaluate whether an applicant can be successful as both a student and a community member.
Considering the New ACT Format
The new 'core' ACT version with an optional science section is a significant shift. While admissions officers evaluate ACT scores similarly across versions, students must check specific institutional policies regarding the science section before opting out.
The Bottom Line on Testing Strategy
Take practice tests for both the SAT and ACT to determine your best fit. If your scores fall within or above a school's reported range and reflect your ability, submit them. If testing is not a strength or a school maintains a true 'no harm' policy, dedicate focus to essays, transcript rigor, and extracurricular involvement.
The college admissions journey can feel overwhelming, but remember, you're not alone. Counselors like myself are here to help you navigate these complexities and find the best path forward. So, keep asking those thoughtful questions, keep exploring your options, and trust the process. You've got this! Click below to watch the full webinar.
